| New York Islanders |
| C | 1. John Tavares |
| 2. Mikhail Grabovski |
| 3. Frans Nielsen |
| 4. Ryan Strome |
| 5. Casey Cizikas |
| 6. Anders Lee |
| L | 1. Michael Grabner |
| 2. Matt Martin |
| 3. Cory Conacher |
| 4. Johan Sundstrom |
| 5. Eric Boulton |
| 6. Brock Nelson |
| 7. Michael Dal Colle |
| R | 1. Kyle Okposo |
| 2. Nikolai Kulemin |
| 3. Josh Bailey |
| 4. Cal Clutterbuck |
| 5. Colin McDonald |
| 6. Joshua Ho-Sang |
| D | 1. Lubomir Visnovsky |
| 2. Travis Hamonic |
| 3. Thomas Hickey |
| 4. Calvin De Haan |
| 5. Matt Carkner |
| 6. Brian Strait |
| 7. Matt Donovan |
| 8. T.J. Brennan |
| 9. Griffin Reinhart |
| G | 1. Jaroslav Halak |
| 2. Chad Johnson |
