Penguins Rumors: Pittsburgh "Unhappy" With Erik Karlsson

The Pittsburgh Penguins are increasingly unhappy with Erik Karlsson’s performance, as the three-time Norris Trophy winner has struggled to meet expectations since his high-profile acquisition. 

Brought in to bolster offensive production from the blue line, Karlsson has instead highlighted defensive vulnerabilities within the team. 

The Penguins currently rank among the league's worst in goals allowed, tied with the Montreal Canadiens at 66, and Karlsson's risky, offensive-focused playstyle has contributed to the problem. 

According to The Athletic’s Josh Yohe, "the organization remains concerned about his game, his nonchalant attitude, and his contract," suggesting a growing frustration with the disconnect between Karlsson’s play and the team’s needs.

well well well.. oprahshrug.gif pic.twitter.com/WfEjN5hCYa

— jo (@genosbest) November 12, 2024

Karlsson’s defensive lapses have been especially glaring on the right side, where his positioning errors are frequently exploited by opponents. 

Leading the NHL in giveaways, he has become a target for opposing offenses, particularly in critical situations. 

Recently, his performance in a 7-1 loss to the Dallas Stars, where the Penguins allowed six goals in the first period, highlighted the costly impact of his defensive struggles. 

Making matters worse, Karlsson’s own comments downplaying these issues have not sat well with team officials. 

Sources report they are "not thrilled" with his self-assessment, viewing it as a "nonchalant" approach that signals a lack of urgency to address these concerns.

While Kyle Dubas sorts out #pens, former Team Sweden head coach and GM Johan Garpenlöv says 🇸🇪 shouldn't have selected Erik Karlsson #4Nations Face-Off.

"His shortcomings in the defensive game are too great in such a short tournament."@hockeysverige:https://t.co/zl2vElSc0m

— Frank Seravalli (@frank_seravalli) November 13, 2024

With two years remaining on his $10 million annual contract and a no-movement clause, Karlsson’s future in Pittsburgh is complicated, but the team may be forced to explore trade options if their defensive woes persist. 

Although he reportedly remains a respected figure in the locker room, his defensive play has limited his value to a roster that needs stability as much as offensive flair. The Penguins, who expected Karlsson to be a game-changer, now face some tough decisions in light of unmet expectations and a disappointing start to the season.

Photo Credit: Bob Frid-Imagn Images