Major Trade Update Between Leafs and Blues

The rumor mill has been churning, folks, and all eyes were on St. Louis and Toronto. Could the Maple Leafs snag Blues captain Brayden Schenn, the coveted veteran? The tension was thick, with whispers of a potential blockbuster deal echoing through the NHL. 

But just when we thought the stage was set, a plot twist emerged from the heart of Missouri, throwing a wrench into the whole production. Reports indicate the Blues are seeking a substantial return, including prospect Easton Cowan and multiple draft picks. 

The Maple Leafs are now evaluating whether Schenn's current value justifies the cost.

Toronto has the pieces to make a deal for Brayden Schenn but as of now haven’t put a package together to make it work. Told, at this point, a deal with the Maple Leafs is unlikely. Could change, but as of now doubtful. ##LeafsForever #stlblues

— Andy Strickland (@andystrickland) February 28, 2025

Is Brayden Schenn Worth the Cost?

Brayden Schenn, at 33 years old, is only a year younger than John Tavares. Although his production remains respectable, signs of regression are apparent, suggesting he may be on the decline of his career. Furthermore, he carries three more years on his contract, meaning Toronto would be investing in a veteran well into his mid-thirties. 

The rumored trade package for Schenn is substantial, reportedly including, at a minimum, highly regarded prospect Easton Cowan, a 2025 second-round pick, and a 2026 first-round pick. 

While Schenn's experience under Craig Berube, his Stanley Cup victory, and his reputation as a strong two-way forward are undeniably appealing, the fundamental question remains: is he the game-changer worthy of such a steep price? 

His scoring output has seen a noticeable decline, shifting from his previous consistent 25+ goal seasons. 

This season, Schenn has recorded 12 goals and 24 assists in 60 games, accompanied by 150 hits and a 50.7% face-off win percentage. However, his shot numbers and defensive metrics have also shown signs of decline, prompting further scrutiny of his current form.

 

A Gamble on Schenn's Potential

For this trade to be considered a success, Schenn would need to significantly elevate his goal production, excel in face-offs, regain his defensive prowess, and contribute substantially to a Stanley Cup victory for Toronto. However, placing such a heavy burden on a 33-year-old veteran carries considerable risk. 

The ultimate question remains: does the potential reward outweigh the substantial risk? Only time will tell.

Image - Christopher Creveling-Imagn