NHL Off-Season Mock Trade: Connor McDavid to the Canadiens Sparks Debate

The 2025 NHL offseason hasn’t even arrived, but Connor McDavid trade rumors are already taking over hockey discussions. While much of the speculation centers on a potential homecoming to Toronto, a new scenario is gaining momentum—an eye-popping deal sending McDavid to the Montreal Canadiens.

Before we dive in, it’s important to note: no credible insider reports suggest the Oilers and Canadiens are actively negotiating. Yet, the hypothetical trade has exploded online—and for compelling reasons.

McDavid becomes eligible for a contract extension this summer, and if no deal is in place by the start of the 2025-26 season, Edmonton could face a franchise-altering decision.

Mock Trade Proposal: McDavid for Hutson and Demidov?

The blockbuster scenario making waves? Connor McDavid to Montreal in exchange for top prospects Lane Hutson and Ivan Demidov.

At 28, McDavid remains in his prime and would command a massive extension—likely in the $15 million AAV range. An eight-year deal would lock him in until age 37, raising questions about Edmonton’s long-term cap flexibility, especially if another playoff disappointment forces a roster rethink.

Meanwhile, Montreal would be parting with two elite young talents. Lane Hutson (21) is a dynamic, offensive defenseman with top-power-play potential, while Ivan Demidov (19) boasts superstar upside as a future first-line forward.

Both are years away from their peak, but neither is a surefire bet to reach McDavid’s otherworldly level.

This kind of seismic trade rarely enters serious discussion, yet the rumor underscores the mounting pressure on Edmonton’s management—and Montreal’s ambition to accelerate their Cup contention. It’s also a testament to McDavid’s unmatched impact: a single player who could transform a franchise overnight.